I had a salesperson I coached lose a $28,000 deal because of her executive summary. Not because of the pricing, that was competitive. Not the because of the solution, that was perfect for their needs. You could tell the problem from her opening paragraph: "We are pleased to present this comprehensive proposal outlining our enterprise-grade solution designed to facilitate the optimization of your operational processes through the implementation of best-in-class methodologies."
The client CEO later told her: "I had no idea what you were actually going to do for us."
Most executives spend 30 seconds scanning your executive summary before deciding whether to read further or pass your proposal to procurement for the "thanks, but no thanks" email.
What if I told you that 90% of your proposal's fate is decided before the reader gets past page one?
Why your executive summary is your make-or-break moment
In 2019 Gartner published a research article showing that 38% of buyers never complete their purchase process. It often starts with executive summaries that are impossible to understand quickly. While your competitors are opening with corporate gratitude speeches and company founding stories, busy decision-makers are looking for one thing: does this solve my problem and is it worth the investment?
I watched a client win a competitive three-way bid with a proposal that was shorter than both competitors. The difference wasn't the solution as all three vendors offered similar capabilities. The CEO called within two hours of receiving their proposal. Not because the solution was revolutionary, but because he immediately understood what they would do and why it mattered.
The other two proposals sat on his desk for weeks because he couldn't figure out what either company was actually proposing to accomplish.
So what exactly is a busy CEO looking for in those first 30 seconds?
Writing for the person who actually signs the check
The executive summary is for the Ratifier, the person who gives the final approval. This isn't necessarily who you've been meeting with. The Ratifier often shows up at the end of your sales process, reviews your proposal with fresh eyes, and makes the go/no-go decision.
The Ratifier's mental checklist looks like this:
- Strategic alignment: Does this move us toward our business goals?
- Risk assessment: What could go wrong, and how likely is it?
- ROI clarity: What's the measurable return on this investment?
- Vendor credibility: Do I trust these people to deliver?
Your executive summary succeeds when it answers these questions in the way the Ratifier thinks about them. Which means you need to structure your executive summary accordingly.
Your executive summary should be a complete proposal in miniature
Here's what most people get wrong about executive summaries: they think it's a teaser for the full proposal. It's not. Your executive summary should be a compressed version of your entire argument using the six universal blocks from proposal structure: Situation, Objectives, Solution, Expertise, Investment, and Value.
If someone read only your executive summary, they should understand your complete proposition. Here's how to structure it:
Situation & Objectives (2-3 sentences): Start with their current state and what needs to change. Use their language, not yours. If they call it "the shop floor," don't write "manufacturing environment."
Solution (2-3 sentences): Your approach, focused on what changes for them. Avoid methodology details.
Expertise (1-2 sentences): Why you're the right choice, with specific credibility that relates to their situation.
Investment & Value (2-3 sentences): Clear cost and quantified returns. Don't hide the price. If your value story is strong, the investment becomes logical.
Notice what's missing from this structure? Your company history, your methodology details, your team bios. Save those for the main proposal sections. The executive summary is about their problem and your solution, period.
Sell the after-picture, not the process
Executives don't buy processes; they buy outcomes. Most often they're not interested in how you'll implement your solution. Instead they want to know what's different when you're done.
Compare these two approaches:
Process-focused: "We'll implement a comprehensive CRM solution using our proven three-phase methodology, beginning with stakeholder interviews and requirements gathering..."
Transformation-focused: "Your sales team will close 23% more deals while spending 40% less time on administrative tasks. Sales managers will have real-time visibility into pipeline health, and your customer service team will see complete interaction history instantly."
The second version paints a picture of success. It uses future tense to help the reader visualize the improved state: "You'll see..." "Your team will..." "Your customers will experience..."
This isn't about removing all process details from your proposal, those belong in your solution section. But your executive summary should focus relentlessly on the transformation you're creating.
The one-page executive summary template
Here's the template I use to win competitive deals:
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Challenge: [Client's situation in their words - 2-3 sentences]
The Opportunity: [What they'll achieve - 2 sentences focusing on business impact]
Our Solution: [How you'll create that transformation - 3-4 sentences, no jargon]
Why [Your Company]: [Your relevant expertise - 2 sentences with specific credibility]
Investment & Returns: [Clear cost and quantified value - 2-3 sentences]
Next Steps: [What happens next - 1 sentence]
Let me show you this template in action, using a technology consulting example:
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Challenge: Your current system struggles to handle real-time data from multiple locations, creating security vulnerabilities and processing delays as you scale to new markets.
The Opportunity: You'll gain faster, more secure data handling that scales effortlessly with expansion, enabling real-time insights across all locations while reducing security risk by 85%.
Our Solution: We'll implement a cloud-based architecture with built-in redundancy and advanced encryption that automatically scales with your growth. Your team will have real-time access to data from all locations through a single, secure interface. Processing speed will improve by 50% while maintaining 99.9% uptime during expansion phases.
Why DataFlow Solutions: We've built similar solutions for 47 companies during high-growth phases, including helping TechStart maintain security compliance as they scaled from 3 to 15 locations. Our cloud architecture team has 12 years of experience in retail expansion technology.
Investment & Returns: The total project investment of $85,000 includes design, development, and first-year support. Based on your current processing volumes, you'll save approximately $140,000 annually through improved efficiency and reduced security risk.
Next Steps: We can begin the technical assessment within two weeks of approval.
Keep your executive summary to 200-250 words maximum. If you need more space, your main proposal sections aren't doing their job.
Five things that kill executive summaries (and how to avoid them)
Even with the right structure, certain mistakes will torpedo your executive summary before the reader gets to your solution:
Starting with gratitude: "Thank you for this opportunity to submit our proposal..." tells the reader this could be any proposal for any company. Start with business impact instead.
Leading with your company story: Nobody cares that you were founded in a garage in 1987. Save your origin story for the company background section, if you include one at all.
Process over outcomes: Describing your implementation methodology instead of what the client will experience when you're done. The executive summary isn't the place for project phases.
Vague value statements: "Improved efficiency" means nothing. "Reduce processing time by 40%" creates a specific expectation you can measure.
Burying the investment: If you're scared to mention price in the executive summary, your value story isn't strong enough. Build value first, then state the investment as a logical next step.
Here's your reality check question: If someone reads your executive summary and nothing else, would they understand exactly what problem you're solving and why it's worth the investment? If the answer is no, you're not ready to send the proposal.
The executive summary is your proposal's sales pitch in miniature. Write for the Ratifier who cares about strategic impact and ROI. Use the six-block structure to ensure completeness. Sell transformation, not process. And keep it to one page maximum.
Most importantly, remember that clarity beats cleverness every time. A decision-maker who understands your solution in 30 seconds is infinitely more likely to approve it than one who needs to schedule a meeting just to figure out what you're proposing to do.
The executive summary is just one piece of the way of writing proposals that actually win deals. The full process, from understanding your buyer's psychology to structuring every section for maximum impact, is what separates the proposals that get filed away from the ones that get approved.
Want to master the complete proposal writing system? Join our newsletter where we dive deep into advanced B2B sales strategies that help you win more deals with less effort.